Laptop Test

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, 25 February 2013

MEASUREMENTS: What 'lo-fi' looks like (SONY CFD-S05).

Posted on 09:10 by Unknown
Name:  Player.jpg Views: 166 Size:  82.8 KB



<Originally posted on Squeezebox Forum Feruary 13, 2013>

I realized over the weekend that it has been at least 10 years since I actually played any cassette tapes! My dad was interested in getting some old cassettes transferred and I discovered both my cassette players at home didn't work.

So, off to the local Wal-Mart-like big block store and I came home with this beauty :-)

The Sony CFD-S05 does a lot for $60. It's a smallish boombox CD player, cassette player, AM/FM radio... Even has a little phono plug input up front for iPod's and the like. Since the cassettes I wanted to transfer were mostly >30 years old, I certainly did not need a Nakamichi. As a "utility" audio player for the kids, although this unit isn't $20 like the absolute cheapest in the store, I suspect this is the kind of lowest end "quality" most of us would be willing to have around the house. Therefore, I figure it might be interesting to measure this unit as a "point of reference" as context to the other measurements and consider what $60 buys.

Set-up: SONY headphone out (MegaBass off) --> 0404USB, shielded phono to RCA RadioShack cables. Test signals burned on Fujifilm CD-R at 24x (no fancy media here or extra-slow 1x burning).

Name:  Summary.png Views: 163 Size:  30.8 KB

As you see, I've added the SB Radio, Boom, and Touch as comparisons. Note that the Radio and Boom were also measured from headphone out while Touch was with the standard RCA line out. Clearly, the Sony was outmatched by all the others. The Sony's dynamic range is about 12-bits due to high noise floor.

The most obvious anomaly is the frequency response - very nasty:
Name:  FR.jpg Views: 181 Size:  55.0 KB

Here's the THD graph:
Name:  THD.jpg Views: 161 Size:  59.2 KB
Again, quite poor. The elevated noise floor is clearly an issue.

Jitter, anyone?
Name:  J-Test_16-44.jpg Views: 161 Size:  43.5 KB

Well, it's not good but... At ~90dB between the 11kHz signal and the tallest sideband, I'd say this is actually not terrible either! I'd be much more concerned about the other results and especially that horrifying frequency response than care about the jitter.

Conclusion?
Not unexpectedly, this is clearly not "hi-fi" (no kiddin'!). Subjectively when I plug in headphones, it's the frequency response that most noticeably makes it sound poor (gutless bass and accentuated treble, no wonder Sony included the "MegaBass" button); plus the noise level is audible with volume up a bit. I suspect that the frequency response curve was purposely "tuned" to make it sound better with the small built-in speakers (single driver) rather than achieve flat response which should be trivial with any modern DAC. Rolling off the low bass to remove rattling & midrange distortions and boosting the treble to compensate for the lack of a true tweeter. To not turn off this compensation when using the headphones is a sign of "cheapness"

Having said the above, also consider that some high-priced gear have really bad measurements yet get praised during subjective evaluation (I'm not going to name names here but look through some of Stereophile's measurements on-line).

Of interest is that the jitter test was the least concerning result even in such an inexpensive unit spinning physical media.

Now you know what a cheap lo-fi mass market boombox measures like in 2013 :-)
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Getting There... (Early HT Room Setup)
    Back from my overseas business trip late last week. It's going to be really busy since I'll be moving to the new house in 1 week. Ma...
  • Information about Internet and its Uses in Our Daily Life
    Information about Internet and its Uses in Our Daily Life How difficult our life would have been if there was no Internet. Think about it. T...
  • MEASUREMENTS: Sony Playstation 1 (PS1) - SCPH-5501 as CD player.
    I got a kick out of this article by Stereophile awhile back (2008): http://www.stereophile.com/cdplayers/708play/ Imagine, audiophiles using...
  • MEASUREMENTS: Part I: Bit-Perfect Audiophile Music Players (Windows).
    Close to a month back, after publishing my TEAC UD-501 results , someone E-mailed me about the use of  JPLAY  with this DAC. Although I had ...
  • How to Transfer Pictures from Camera to Computer
    How to Transfer Pictures from Camera to Computer Despite the significant increase in storage capacity on memory cards in digital cameras, mo...
  • MEASUREMENTS: Part II: Bit-Perfect Audiophile Music Players - JPLAY (Windows).
    There's something happening here, What it is ain't exactly clear. -- Buffalo Springfield Welcome to Part II of the "Bit-Perfect...
  • MEASUREMENTS: TosLink digital optical audio cables.
    Let us now finish off testing the digital audio cables at my disposal. Already we're seen that USB  and coaxial SPDIF cables did not ha...
  • GUEST REVIEW & MEASUREMENTS: The Dr. Frank's "Best-Coaxial-Digital"™ SPDIF Cable.
    By Keaton I. Goulden-Eyre III, Esq. Two months ago, I had the good fortune to meet my independently wealthy friend Stephen at the local smok...
  • MEASUREMENTS: PCM to DSD Upsampling Effects (JRiver MC19 Beta).
    We're continuing to see a push into the DSD domain with renewed talk of music release as digital downloads requiring the purchase of a D...
  • MEASUREMENTS: Logitech Touch TT3 Mod.
    Here's some data on my Touch with Soundcheck's Touch Toolbox 3.0 ( http://soundcheck-audio.blogspot.ca/...oolbox-30.html ) software ...

Categories

  • Apple
  • Computers Tutorials
  • FaceBook
  • Hardware
  • India
  • iTunes
  • Online Advertising
  • Web
  • Window XP Tips

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (62)
    • ►  November (2)
    • ►  October (4)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (2)
    • ►  July (3)
    • ►  June (8)
    • ►  May (10)
    • ►  April (6)
    • ►  March (4)
    • ▼  February (18)
      • MEASUREMENTS: AUNE X1 (Mark I) [UPDATED].
      • MEASUREMENTS: Oppo BDP-105 as USB DAC.
      • MEASUREMENTS: Asus XONAR Essence One [Updated June...
      • MEASUREMENTS: MUSE Mini TDA1543x4 NOS DAC! [UPDATED]
      • MEASUREMENTS: What 'lo-fi' looks like (SONY CFD-S05).
      • MEASUREMENTS: Logitech Squeezebox Boom & Radio.
      • MEASUREMENTS: Behringer DEQ2496.
      • MEASUREMENTS: Logitech Squeezebox Transporter [Upd...
      • MEASUREMENTS: Logitech Touch TT3 Mod.
      • MEASUREMENTS: Logitech Touch as transport!
      • MEASUREMENTS: Logitech Squeezebox Touch. [Updated ...
      • MEASUREMENTS: "Slim Devices" Squeezebox 3 [Updated...
      • MEASUREMENTS: E-MU 0404USB.
      • Musings & Gear Measurements Coming...
      • High Bitrate MP3 Internet Blind Test: Part 4 - SUB...
      • High Bitrate MP3 Internet Blind Test: Part 3 - DIS...
      • High Bitrate MP3 Internet Blind Test: Part 2 - RES...
      • High Bitrate MP3 Internet Blind Test: Part 1 - PRO...
    • ►  January (1)
  • ►  2012 (2)
    • ►  December (1)
    • ►  May (1)
  • ►  2011 (33)
    • ►  August (33)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile